Joe Manganiello And Caitlin O’Connor'S Surprising Move: Why They Left Hollywood Behind

From Hollywood Hills to Pennsylvania Posh

Joe Manganiello and his stunning fiancée, Caitlin O’Connor, are waving goodbye to the glitz of Hollywood as they embrace the tranquil life in Pennsylvania's Mount Lebanon. The Magic Mike star, 49, and O’Connor, 36, who starred in Winning Time: The Rise of the Lakers Dynasty, announced last month their bold decision to leave behind the bright lights of Los Angeles. After two decades of Tinseltown living, the duo is returning to their roots in a serene suburb of Pittsburgh, where both stars grew up.

“The crime in Los Angeles is at an all-time high,” O’Connor shared with Fox News Digital. “We were thinking about it for a long time, and the right house happened to come up in Pittsburgh. It was perfect for us.”

Shifting Industry Dynamics

O’Connor, with candid insight, explained that L.A.'s allure as the entertainment capital is fading fast. “L.A. is no longer the entertainment capital of the world,” she pointed out, emphasizing how auditions have pivoted to virtual platforms. With premieres and productions branching out to locations like New York and New Jersey, and a noticeable shift overseas, the couple felt the industry moving away from its Hollywood cradle. “For the most part, everything is on Zoom,” she noted, highlighting a world where even seasoned L.A. professionals are packing their bags for overseas projects.

Falling in Love with Seasons

The couple’s venture into Pennsylvania isn't just about getting back to their roots. It’s also about rekindling their love for the seasons, something elusive in sunny California. “Our first night here, we woke up to the season’s first snow,” O’Connor reminisced. With romantic charm, she shared a personal moment of seeing Manganiello shovel snow for nearly three hours. "I fell more in love with him," she gushed, capturing the couple's heartwarming transition to their new snowy reality.

Manganiello and O’Connor, who have been inseparable since they started dating in 2023, celebrated their engagement in October 2025. The joyous news was shared with fans through a sweet Instagram post, featuring their adorable chihuahua, Bubbles, and a caption marking their engagement date: “June 24th, 2025.”

Looking Forward

This move marks a new chapter for Manganiello, who previously was married to Sofia Vergara for seven years until their amicable split in July 2023. As they settle into their new life in Pennsylvania, both Joe and Caitlin are eagerly embracing this fresh start, away from the hustle and bustle of Los Angeles.

In the meantime, fans can't help but keep an eye on their social media feeds for more heartwarming updates from the couple as they continue their journey in the Keystone State.